By Dominic Jones
LAST week, IR Web Report published results of our snap survey of the readability of 40 companies’ new executive pay discussions.
We found that the average compensation discussion and analysis section in firms’ most recent proxy statements has the same readability level as a Harvard Law Journal article. They probably would not be understood by two-thirds of U.S. adults — this despite requirements that they be written in plain English.
It seems that the problem has not gone unnoticed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. In a speech yesterday, chairman Christopher Cox said the commission was “seeing examples of overlawyering that are leading to 30- and 40-page long executive compensation sections in proxy statements.”
He said there were cases of “slavish adherence to boilerplate disclosure” including companies having columns in the summary compensation tables even when they have nothing to report in them.
Cox said that while the SEC will allow companies leeway to get used to the new rules, “the plain English part of executive compensation will be increasingly strictly enforced in the coming year.”
Update: The Washington Post via Bloomberg covers the plain English issue.
Related: CEO pay disclosures dense as academic texts
IRWebReport.com was founded by Dominic Jones in February 2001 to promote best practices for online investor relations communications. All articles on IR Web Report are unpaid editorial. If we write about any company with which we have a business relationship, either directly through sponsorship or indirectly through consulting services, we fully disclose the relationship in the article itself. Our standards of disclosure are higher than any other publication or association in the IR industry. We disclose both direct and indirect relationships. Sponsors are identified as such in the right sidebar. Anyone is able to see our sponsorship fees. Without sponsors, we would not be able to continue publishing on a regular schedule. Please support independent content in the IR industry.
[...] Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) chairman Christopher Cox blamed lawyers for “overlawyering” the new disclosures companies have been filing. They’re too long, he said in a recent speech, vowing that the SEC will take a harder line on the plain English requirements in the coming year. [...]